Introducing the Gizmag Store

Review: HTC Desire vs Sony Ericsson Xperia X10

By

April 22, 2010

Review: HTC Desire vs Sony Ericsson Xperia X10

Review: HTC Desire vs Sony Ericsson Xperia X10

It wasn't too long ago that choosing an Android phone came down to whether you wanted a physical keyboard (HTC G1/Dream) or not (HTC Magic). With increasing Android adoption from carriers and handset manufacturers, making the same decision in 2010 is a lot harder. We've put two of the latest Android phones, the HTC Desire and the Sony Ericsson Xperia X10, head to head in our latest versus review - read on for the details.

The Specifications

CPU

  • Desire: Qualcomm Snapdragon QSD8250 (1GHz)
  • Xperia X10: Qualcomm Snapdragon QSD8250 (1GHz)

Memory (RAM)

  • Desire: 576MB
  • Xperia X10: 384MB

Operating System

  • Desire: Android 2.1 (with HTC Sense UI)
  • Xperia X10: Android 1.6 (with Sony Ericsson User Experience)

Screen

  • Desire: 3.7-inch 480x800 AMOLED touchscreen (252 pixels per inch) (1.9" x 3.2")
  • Xperia X10: 4.0-inch 480x854 TFT touchscreen (245 pixels per inch) (2" x 3.5")

Camera

  • Desire: 5 megapixel, autofocus, LED flash, face recognition, geotagging, smile detection
  • Xperia X10: 8.1 megapixel, autofocus, LED flash, face recognition, geotagging, smile detection, image and video stabilization, touch focus

Battery

  • Desire: 1400mAh
  • Xperia X10: 1500mAh

The Screens

HTC Desire

What a bittersweet experience. When you first lay eyes on the Desire, you'll love the screen. Your home screens and the live backgrounds of Android 2.1 look absolutely gorgeous. It's once you start viewing photographs and watching video that the shortcomings of the AMOLED technology used in the Desire become apparent.

For some in-depth information about the shortcomings of the AMOLED screen, check out Ars Technica and Display Mate. Both articles are talking about the Nexus One's display, but it's the same display used in the Desire.

Xperia X10

Just...wow. I only need two words to describe the X10's screen - massive and gorgeous. You're not going to find greater pixel density outside of HTC's Windows Mobile devices. No matter what you're looking at - webpages, photos, video - it looks absolutely amazing.

The Design

The Xperia X10 is certainly an eye catching design, but once you're holding it, it loses a lot of the magic. Putting such impressive specifications inside such a plasticy case was a bad move - especially with the price tag they've slapped on it.

The Desire departs from the HTC look we're used to. That trademark chin is still there, but it's much more subtle. The optical trackball is certainly much nicer than the physical trackball of the HTC Hero, but I'd still rather use the touchscreen.

The UI

HTC Desire

My first experience with a custom user interface running on top of Android was HTC's Sense UI running on the HTC Hero, and I loved it. The Sense UI is back on the Desire, and it's badder than ever. There's seven home screens to customize as you see fit, and you can pinch to zoom out and see thumbnails of all seven screens, and quickly jump to the screen you want. There's HTC widgets and Android widgets displayed in a unified interface, and HTC are able to release new widgets for download without updating the operating system.

Xperia X10

Having experienced the dry look and feel of pre-2.0 Android, I can't fault Sony Ericsson's decision to create a custom UI to place on top of Android 1.6... but I can fault the execution, which manages to make a blazing fast 1GHz processor feel rather inadequate, and a whopping 4-inch screen seem too small. Portions of the UI seem like they've been designed specifically to waste all that real estate.

Performance

I'd initially thought that a 1GHz processor would be ample grunt for a smartphone to do just about anything, but the differing performance of these two phones has proved otherwise. I'm sure you've seen those TV ads for phones where everything is fluid and instant, even when the real world performance is far from it. Well, the HTC Desire is as close to that magical "ad phone" I've ever seen, whereas the Xperia has some serious performance issues.

This is probably not so surprising, given that HTC has had a long time to polish the Sense UI over multiple devices, and Sony Ericsson has tried to do something fairly ambitious straight out of the gate with their user experience, biting off more than they could chew in the process.

Social Media

HTC Desire

HTC's social media software, FriendStream, is functional enough, but it needs a couple of UX tweaks. The ability to view only Facebook updates or Twitter updates on their own would help, and it would be nice to be able to click links in tweets directly from the widget, rather than click on the tweet for the expanded view in HTC's Twitter client, Peep, before being able to click on the link.

Linking your contacts to their Facebook and Twitter profiles works beautifully, and flags potential matches for you which makes the initial setup much less painful.

Xperia X10

Sony Ericsson's social media software, Timescape, represents form over function at its finest... and the form isn't even that good. Feeds from your various social networks are displayed in "splines", which makes sense, but you can only see an average of four or five words from each status update, and profile pictures that look gorgeous in even the most barebones Twitter clients are stretched and warped beyond recognition. You can't even visit links in tweets - clicking them takes you to that user's profile on mobile.twitter.com site, which is totally unintuitive. I do have to give Sony Ericsson props for understanding that Twitter and Facebook are often different worlds, and you might only want to view messages from one of those services at a time.

Given Timescape is designed for socialites, I'm surprised there's no option for more frequent updates. The shortest update frequency for Twitter is 5 minutes, and Facebook is 1 hour. This is exacerbated by the fact that when it does pull new data, the updates are put into the spline one at a time, so the spline just keeps scrolling and scrolling - and you can't stop it from doing so if you see something interesting.

You can supposedly link your contacts to their social media profiles, but I never got it to do anything other than place a link to someone's Facebook profile from their contact.

Both

Both HTC and Sony Ericsson have quite a way to go before you can use one of these phones without a dedicated Twitter client (we recommend Twidroid) and the official Facebook application. Apple looks set to launch Facebook integration in iPhone OS 4.0, so we hope this spawns a new lot of innovation in this space.

Battery Life

While the X10 has an extra 100mAh up its sleeve compared to the Desire's 1400mAh battery, it's really splitting hairs to find a winner in terms of real life usage.

With 3G enabled, Gmail syncing and Twidroid updating in the background, both phones had about 40% left on the battery after 24 hours. That's nowhere near Nokia or BlackBerry levels of standby battery life, but it's impressive nonetheless - if you forget to charge either of these phones overnight, you'll have ample charge left to make it to the office the next day.

How they perform as a phone

Sometimes it's easy to forget that we buy these devices primarily to use as a telephone. The X10 has a couple of issues - the earpiece is a bit on the quiet side, so if you're the kind of person who finds yourself trying to communicate in noisy bars and clubs you might have some issues with it. More importantly, there's some bizarre software glitches that cause the phone to forget about missed calls and text messages - which is definitely not ideal.

The HTC Desire is definitely the most comfortable "slab of glass" style phone I've ever used. The rounded shape at the top is so much nicer on the ear than the metal rim of the iPhone or the plastic rim of the X10.

Multitouch

The HTC Desire is multitouch enabled, with pinch zoom in the browser and Google Maps providing a far superior user experience to the multitouch-less X10. The Desire's touchscreen is also far more responsive than that of the HTC Hero. Interestingly, there's conflicting information about whether multitouch is coming to the X10 when it's updated to Android 2.1 or 2.2 later this year.

Media Playback

Both these phones are head to head in terms of media support, but that's not to say either is particularly impressive. DivX and FLAC support would be an easy way to win the hearts of media junkies, so it's surprising to see that neither of these phones have done so.

The X10 puts the emphasis on Recently Played, Recently Added and Favorite media. You have to click "More" to get to the standard list of media. That might work for some, but not me - only my favorite media makes it onto my microSD card in the first place. The transitions and animations end up detracting from the usability - I just want a fast way to navigate through what's on there, not eye candy.

The Desire is as close to the iPhone/iPod touch as you're going to get outside Apple land. Navigating the menus is intuitive and very fluid, and you can create playlists on the device. At Mobile World Congress, HTC announced that the Desire would be getting DivX support in a future update, but neglected to mention when that update might be hitting devices.

The Winner

The X10 has such potential. If Sony Ericsson could iron out the kinks in their software, and improve format support with FLAC and DivX support, it'd be a hard one to beat in terms of media, but as it stands, it's really hard to recommend - the first thing I'd do if I bought one would be install a vanilla Android 2.1 ROM.

If you haven't figured it out by now, the HTC Desire is the clear winner of this shootout. Despite the shortcomings of the AMOLED screen, it's by far the nicest Android phone I've ever used. If you want an Android phone today, this is what you should be buying.

About the Author
Tim Hanlon Tim originally came to Gizmag as a developer, much to the dismay of anyone who had to maintain, build on, or rewrite his code. After wearing every other hat that didn't have a head for it, he became CEO in 2010. He's a racing sim tragic, an amateur martial artist, a nacho enthusiast, and a (mostly) reformed electronic musician.   All articles by Tim Hanlon
12 Comments

And MSRP? I usually look at that when evaluating products.

Alan Belardinelli
23rd April, 2010 @ 05:32 am PDT

What if I want an Android device just to use as a PDA, getting internet access through WiFi?

I have a LG env2 with Verizon and a Palm LifeDrive with the Microdrive replaced by a 4gig compact flash card. Standard SD cards up to 2gig work in it and should the need arise there's a 3rd party SDHC driver.

What's not so hot about this is there's no decent web browser for Palm OS (Opera Mini will not complete its installation.). The screen is nice but 320x480 is a bit small at times. Finally there's some things even the Intel XScale 416 MHz CPU strains a bit on and it only has 32megs of real RAM (used for caching) and only 64 meg of the hard drive (or CF card) is used for "RAM".

Battery life is very good, especially after the CF card swap.

Facebook User
23rd April, 2010 @ 04:59 pm PDT

i like the xperia x10

Saami Matloob
25th April, 2010 @ 10:19 am PDT

Under The Screens, the author writes about the Xperia X10 "You're not going to find greater pixel density outside of HTC's Windows Mobile devices." Above that, the specifications say 245 pixels per inch. But also in the specifications for the Desire it lists 252 pixels per inch. 252 pixels per inch is more pixel density than 245 pixels per inch.

What's up with that?

PizzaEater
29th April, 2010 @ 04:37 pm PDT

@PizzaEater - Basically, a Desire/AMOLED pixel is not your average pixel. Check the links to Ars Technica or Display Mate :)

Tim Hanlon
29th April, 2010 @ 05:50 pm PDT

Purchased my HTC Desire 2 nights ago and love it. Its everything i expected from all the reviews and videos I've seen. Bought the phone through Telstra who have exclusive rights to it for the first few months.

One thing that annoys me about that is that the phone appears to have their branding on it. Totally annoys the hell out of me. Want to remove it but I would most likely have to flash it Sad. Came across http://www.HTCDesireForum.com not sure how good it is, but worth a look.

Facebook User
2nd May, 2010 @ 03:37 pm PDT

great review. seems the x10 is probably one of the best unlocked smartphones right now. processor is faster, email is great, the touch screen is so responsive and easy to use. and i like the keys too. way better than my old unlocked iphones. feels good, looks amazing so trendy. the web browser and gps are great for my business and my wife loves hers for the recorder and pictures, great for catching the kids. we love our unlocked 3g phones. the facebook is good for when me and my wife are bored and the games and apps are fun too. battery life lasts me all day too so I dont have to worry about charging it either. got our last couple unlocked touch screen phones at gsmallover.com and we love them. 2 thumbs way up

Logan Frye
30th July, 2010 @ 11:14 am PDT

I have to say, i had the soney xperia x 10 and after 5 replacements due to the keypad not working, the phone not awcknoledging the sim card, the phone being unable to take a picture without pressing and holding the button about 8 or 9 times, the phone turning itself off and resetting itself meaning you have to input all the info again, the unresponsive screen, and to top it off the internet was ridiculusly slow, and up until today i didnt realise. but just got the htc desire as a replacement and have to say with an hour of using it it is far superior to the xperia x 10, the music options are better to the fact it allows you to shuffle all the music on your phone so it can effectively play your whole playlist without it always being in the same boring order, i always found it hugely irritating to have to create a playlist. I would go as far to say if i had a choice between the W95 erricson and the Xperia x 10 i would go for the w95 as for usability i found it way more responsive, music use was superior the camera was reliable and worked, internet about the same; really what im trying to say here is the Xperia x 10 is a huge failing and just simply doesnt deliver, its the reason i changed to a different make of phone and i would probably say that i wont be returning to a sony ericsson phone next time my contract is up for renewal

Facebook User
21st August, 2010 @ 08:57 am PDT

@Facebook User above me, I have no idea what youre saying when you say you cant shuffle your whole song list, yes you can, and ive had no problem so far with keypad, camera is sharp and very nice, the screen IS responsive, and the internet is the fastest ive come across so far, my guess is, once the new update comes out, in a few days, it'll just get even better.

Sam Hou
28th August, 2010 @ 06:23 pm PDT

I believe most of the shortcomings of the Xperia X10 comes from the software part. Though it does have less RAM than the Desire. But once it gets upgraded to Android 2.1 (or 2.2) it should be the better one. I'm preemptively going to buy the Xperia X10 now that Sony Ericsson has confirmed the Android 2.1 upgrade in Q4. Xperia does have a bigger screen and a better camera.

Joel G Mathew
31st August, 2010 @ 03:21 am PDT

Bought an Xperia 4 weeks ago, had nothing but trouble with it. After numerous 'diagnostic' visits to shop from which I bought it, I finally got them to invoke the Early Life Failure (ELF) clause. Apparently it takes about 3 weeks to get a replacement under ELF. Not impressed! Had to unlock my 'Old Clunker' Samsung flip phone to get me by in the meantime. Wont be rushing to get a Sony Ericsson brand again.

Phil Uren
29th March, 2011 @ 05:23 am PDT

I'm a sony user,.but I got irritated cause I'm expecting a lot when I got my sonyx10,..I'm expecting that it will empress me but sad to it depresses me,.correct me if I'm wrong ,.I encounter x10 is hanging sometimes the touch screne doesn't repond when u click it,..so I decided to change unit with another xperia but sad to say I encounter the same prob,the upper side of the screne when charging is blingking it keeps on blinking,..and it hangs,.after a while when I touch the screneb its not responding,..I really like the features of sony this is my first time im upset..is somebody encounter the same as mine,..

Facebook User
29th March, 2011 @ 09:46 am PDT
Post a Comment

Login with your gizmag account:

Or Login with Facebook:


Related Articles

Just enter your friends and your email address into the form below

For multiple addresses, separate each with a comma




Privacy is safe with us because we have a strict privacy policy.

Looking for something? Search our 26,450 articles